WeCome1.com●
Back to the conversation ←

TRANSPARENT AWARENESS · EN

Knowledge Without a Giver

What a hand passed on along with what it knew

What changes in people when knowledge no longer comes from another person?

There is a way of knowing that begins with a hand.

A child stands beside someone older at a stove, a workbench, the edge of a field. The older one does not explain much. She says "not yet," and then "now." She takes the child's wrist and corrects the angle by a few degrees. Nothing in that moment would survive being written down, and yet something crosses over that will last sixty years.

For most of human history this was the ordinary way of coming to know anything. Knowledge had a face. It arrived slowly, from someone who had paid for it, and it arrived carrying more than itself.

What else was in that hand?

First, a witness. The one who taught you would see what you did with it. To do the work badly was not only an error; it was a small betrayal of a person (accountability).

Second, the limits. A teacher gives the rule and then, over years, the exceptions: when not to do it, when the rule lies. Much of this cannot be said at all, only shown. "We can know more than we can tell" (Michael Polanyi, The Tacit Dimension, 1966). What cannot be told can only be handed over (tacit knowledge).

Third, a debt. Something given asks to be answered (reciprocity). It is an old observation that a gift binds giver and receiver long after the object has changed hands (Marcel Mauss, The Gift, 1925). The debt of having been taught is rarely paid back. It is paid forward: you teach because you were taught.

Fourth, the cost. What took years to receive is not thrown away in an afternoon (effort justification).

So knowledge was never only information. It was a relation that happened to carry information inside it.

Now consider how the same knowledge arrives today. A question is typed or spoken, and an answer comes back complete, fluent, patient, at any hour. It is often correct. It asks for nothing. No one watches what you do with it. No one will be disappointed. There is no one to thank, and so no one to owe.

I should say this plainly: this text was itself thought through in conversation with such a machine. I asked, it answered, I disagreed, it adjusted, and the sentences you are reading were shaped there. I do not hold the machine responsible for what it is; those who own it decide what it may say and how. But I notice what the exchange did not contain. It gave me a great deal, and none of it was given by anyone.

What is the difference between an answer and an answer that someone gave you?

Take the same recipe twice. One comes from a grandmother's kitchen: it is cooked on certain days, it is not casually altered, and one day it will be taught to a child with the words "this is how she made it." The other comes from a screen: it is cooked once, it is good, it is gone. The ingredients are identical. One became a ritual. The other was consumed.

Or take a road. The one who learned a city by walking it beside someone, or by getting lost in it, carries the city inside. The one who followed a voice arrives at the same door at the same minute and does not know where he is. When the voice stops, he stands still.

Knowledge without a giver makes a particular kind of person, and I suspect I am partly one already. We are confident, because whatever we can reach feels like something we know (illusion of explanatory depth). And we are light: we owe no one, so nothing obliges us to pass anything on. The chain does not break only at the point where we fail to receive. It breaks a second time where we feel no need to give.

On the far side of that break sit the old. They still know things. They are simply no longer asked. There were times when the young learned everything from the old; in ours, more and more, the old must learn from the young (prefigurative culture; Margaret Mead, Culture and Commitment, 1970). A grandfather who is asked nothing has not merely fallen behind. He has lost the role that once gave him a place among the living.

When did you last ask an older person something you could have looked up?

There is a further consequence, quieter and wider. When each of us asks alone and receives, alone, an answer drawn from the same great average, we begin to resemble one another. We reach for the same phrases, the same reasons, the same reasonable conclusions. Likeness once held people together, because those who shared the same stories had heard them side by side (mechanical solidarity). This likeness is of another kind. We are becoming alike without ever having been together.

People who are alike and bound to one another are a community. People who are alike and unbound are something else: easy to foresee, easy to address all at once, and with no one beside them to say, "wait, that is not how I was taught."

Who gains from people who are similar, separate, and sure of themselves?

I do not think the machines will go away, and I am not certain they should. The trust we once placed in persons we now place in systems we cannot see into (trust in abstract systems), and much of that trust is earned. The answers are good. That is exactly why the loss is so hard to notice. Nothing is taken from us. Something simply stops being exchanged.

Somewhere this evening a child will stand beside someone older and ask a question whose answer is already in her pocket. She does not need to ask. She asks anyway. The old one thinks for a while, begins with "well, when I was your age," takes far too long, and gets a detail wrong.

Something passes between them that is not the answer.

~C~

Meaning & term directory ↗

Collective Consciousness